Something my old piano teacher once said about Christmas.
Post Reply   Forum

Posted by: Ihavenoname ®

11/23/2023, 00:40:20

Author Profile Mail author Edit

Yes, it's been awhile since I've posted. 

But anyways, ahead of the holidays, I've vaguely remembered a conversation I had with my piano teacher about Christmas during my childhood (approximately more than a decade ago). One time, he told me about how Christmas was supposed to be a time of gathering with your loved ones, not merely buying gifts. He then talks about how capitalism ruined Christmas: combining both has perpetuated people's buying habits. So, instead of celebrating Christmas as intended, many shop around and take advantage of discounts (not exactly what he said, but that's what I vaguely recalled). Hence, I see his interpretation as "item giveaway day."

His other frustration is that stores and advertisements abuse Christmas Eve to attract more customers to buy their goods. So, people will remember to start shopping first thing during holiday season. Furthermore, he claimed that most people "don't really understand the true meaning of Christmas." He isn't a Christian, but I think he mentioned that it was supposed to be about celebrating the birth of Jesus Christ. My knowledge of Christmas and Christianity are a ways off, so I can't offer my opinion on that.

Finally, my teacher offered an alternate take on what Christmas should be about (from what I can recall): celebrating life, doing good for others, and spending time with your family.

I'm not making any arguements for or against capitalism in regards to Christmas. I just happen to recall such discussion as we approach December. But I will surely remember that interesting conversation I had with him. No matter what you think, he does make an interesting point (whether you agree with him or not).

Have a happy and safe Thanksgiving Day.






Modified by Ihavenoname at Thu, Nov 23, 2023, 00:47:11


Post Reply | Recommend | Alert View All   Previous | Next | Current page
Like much of society, Christmas HAS been manipulated to man's will and not God's.
Re: Something my old piano teacher once said about Christmas. -- Ihavenoname Post Reply Top of thread Forum

Posted by: Robertb ®

11/23/2023, 23:15:59

Author Profile Mail author Edit
It is over commercialized.
It is/has become a secular holiday.
It has become a lot of group think. "This neighborhood decorates and if you do not, we will shun you". "This neighborhood does NOT decorate and your garish displays need to be banned." "This neighborhood is multi-cultural and your 'christian ways' are triggering to the many non-christians here."

The celebration of the birth of our savior has been forcefully and systematically diminished. It is about how you appear to your fellow man (and women, and trans, and ....). 
"Christmas songs" are more about 'winter conditions' and maybe decorations. They should stay secular and avoid the conflict of religion. Call it a Holiday tree, and not a Christmas tree.

"celebrating life, doing good for others, and spending time with your family." That is not a bad description. Celebrate life, and the promise of eternal life thru Christ's birth, death, and resurrection. Doing good for others, is basically the Golden Rule. Family is not just your blood relatives, but the Family of God. Join with like minded people to amplify they good and help others join you.

IMO, "God is Love". Love God. Love your neighbor as yourself. Love all people. (You can hate the sin, but not the sinner.)  

I am not Catholic, but I am a fan of something Sir Francis of Asceses reported said: "Preach the gospel. If you MUST, use words." 
Be God like and be Love. That is the true reason for Christmas.








Post Reply | Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Top of thread Previous | Next | Current page
Yes. Just. This.
Re: Like much of society, Christmas HAS been manipulated to man's will and not God's. -- Robertb Post Reply Top of thread Forum

Posted by: LateForLunch ®

11/24/2023, 19:56:21

Author Profile Mail author Edit








Post Reply | Recommend | Alert Where am I? Original Top of thread Previous | Next | Current page


Forum     Back